Live-in Guardians
Live-in Guardians

Landmark Judgement in Court of Appeal

February 09, 2022

The Court of Appeal recently gave guidance on the issue of possession claims and the “tenant vs licensee” distinction in the Property Guardianship model.

It has been held that the occupiers of a building (Guardians) must satisfy the court that they have a realistic prospect of defending a possession claim, to avoid a summary possession order being made against them at a first possession hearing. Additionally, even if occupiers (Guardians) claim to enjoy exclusive possession of any building, this on its own is not sufficient to claim any tenancy exists and that the court must have regard to the terms of the contract.

A previous judgement given in the High Court applied a lower threshold as to whether a Guardian (or Tenant) had the right to a full hearing, which would have delayed matters by many months and would have made the Guardian model unworkable.

Thankfully, the Judge in the Court of Appeal acknowledged that it was essential to the provision of guardian services that the property could be handed back when required.

In summary, the risk of a property owner not obtaining vacant possession when required has been significantly reduced.

More news from Live-in Guardians

Live-in Guardians

Property Guardian Scheme

In today’s challenging property market, owners of vacant commercial buildings face numerous risks, including vandalism, squatting, and significant maintenance costs.
Live-in Guardians

How to Protect Your Empty Commercial Building

Vacant commercial properties are magnets for trouble. Whether it’s squatters, vandals, metal theft, or fire hazards, the risks associated with an unoccupied building are high—and the costs can escalate quickly.
Live-in Guardians

Keeping Empty Buildings Secure and Active

Empty commercial properties are more than just unused space—they’re exposed assets that can quickly become a financial and legal burden.
Live-in Guardians

Why Boarding Up Your Commercial Property is a Risky Mistake

When a commercial property becomes vacant, owners often consider boarding it up as a quick security measure. While this might seem like a practical solution to deter trespassers, it actually does the opposite—advertising to the world that your building is empty and vulnerable.